A Complete View Of The Shakspere Controversy PDF Download

This historic book may have numerous typos and missing text. Purchasers can usually download a free scanned copy of the original book (without typos) from the publisher. Not indexed. Not illustrated. 1861 edition. Excerpt: ... chapter vii. The Pebktns Folio.--Philological Tests. So soon as the manuscript corrections of Mr. Test-words _.., i i and test Lollier s ioho, 1632, were promulgated, verbal critics phrases, cast about for such intrinsic indications of genuineness or spuriousness as those corrections might present. The obvious method of testing the genuineness of the corrections was to select a word or phrase which had the appearance of being modern in sense, or idiom, and by an induction of instances in which the word is employed by writers of the last two centuries to prove, or at least to attempt to prove, the negative, that such word or phrase was not in use at all, or in a particular sense, till a certain period; and of course if that period were subsequent to the ostensible date of the manuscript notes, the " old corrector" would be degraded into a modern simulator. Nothing is so slippery as the proof of a negative. In the case of the fabrications of Chatterton, as in those of the Irelands, the spelling alone ought to have been sufficient evidence of fraud; but in the absence of a knowledge of obsolete orthography, the frequent recurrence of yts or its ought still to have been conclusive evidence of the spuriousness of the ma-The test.... word its ap nuscripts. In this case the negative was susceptible pHed to the of proof, and has since been proved. It is this: geries.d fr" the genitive its does not occur in English literals ture till 1622. The first folio of Shakspere is the earliest dated printed book in which the word is found. Thus: --" How sometimes Nature will betray it's folly? It's tendernesse f and make it selfe a Pastime To harder bosomes?"--Winter's Tale, act i. sc. 2. Dean Trench greatly understates the fact when he says he believes it...